Free PDF The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography, by Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen
Excellent The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen publication is always being the most effective close friend for spending little time in your workplace, night time, bus, and also anywhere. It will certainly be a great way to simply look, open, and check out guide The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen while because time. As recognized, experience and skill don't constantly had the much cash to acquire them. Reading this publication with the title The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen will certainly allow you recognize much more things.
The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography, by Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen
Free PDF The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography, by Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen
Idea in deciding on the most effective book The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen to read this day can be acquired by reading this web page. You can locate the most effective book The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen that is sold in this globe. Not only had the books published from this country, however additionally the other nations. And now, we intend you to read The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen as one of the reading products. This is just one of the very best publications to gather in this website. Check out the page as well as search the books The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen You could locate lots of titles of guides supplied.
Obtaining the books The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen now is not sort of challenging way. You can not only choosing publication store or collection or borrowing from your pals to read them. This is a very basic method to precisely obtain guide by online. This on the internet publication The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen can be among the alternatives to accompany you when having leisure. It will not squander your time. Think me, the e-book will reveal you brand-new point to review. Simply invest little time to open this on the internet e-book The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen and also review them anywhere you are now.
Sooner you get guide The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen, quicker you can enjoy reviewing the publication. It will be your resort to maintain downloading guide The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen in given link. This way, you can actually decide that is served to obtain your own book online. Right here, be the first to obtain guide qualified The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen and also be the initial to recognize exactly how the author indicates the notification and knowledge for you.
It will certainly believe when you are going to pick this book. This motivating The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen publication can be checked out entirely in specific time relying on how frequently you open and also review them. One to bear in mind is that every e-book has their own production to obtain by each visitor. So, be the good reader as well as be a better individual after reading this e-book The Myth Of Continents: A Critique Of Metageography, By Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen
In this thoughtful and engaging critique, geographer Martin W. Lewis and historian Kären Wigen reexamine the basic geographical divisions we take for granted, and challenge the unconscious spatial frameworks that govern the way we perceive the world. Arguing that notions of East vs. West, First World vs. Third World, and even the sevenfold continental system are simplistic and misconceived, the authors trace the history of such misconceptions. Their up-to-the-minute study reflects both on the global scale and its relation to the specific continents of Europe, Asia, and Africa—actually part of one contiguous landmass.
The Myth of Continents sheds new light on how our metageographical assumptions grew out of cultural concepts: how the first continental divisions developed from classical times; how the Urals became the division between the so-called continents of Europe and Asia; how countries like Pakistan and Afghanistan recently shifted macroregions in the general consciousness.
This extremely readable and thought-provoking analysis also explores the ways that new economic regions, the end of the cold war, and the proliferation of communication technologies change our understanding of the world. It stimulates thinking about the role of large-scale spatial constructs as driving forces behind particular worldviews and encourages everyone to take a more thoughtful, geographically informed approach to the task of describing and interpreting the human diversity of the planet.
- Sales Rank: #840280 in Books
- Published on: 1997-08-11
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.00" h x 1.00" w x 6.00" l, 1.20 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 383 pages
Amazon.com Review
If you consider geography an objective science, think again. According to Martin W. Lewis and Karen E. Wigen, even the concept of continents is open to interpretation. Why, for example, do Europeans consider their little peninsula a whole continent while the vast territories of India and China are mere subcontinents? Contrast this worldview with that of the Indian mapmakers who depicted South Asia as the world's largest land mass and Europe as marginalized "hat-wearing islands." During the Cold War, the world was even further divided, this time into first, second, and third worlds. But how you classify the various regions of the world, Lewis and Wigen posit in The Myth of Continents, depends very much on where you happen to be standing at the time.
Having bravely exposed the ethnocentrism at the heart of geography, Lewis and Wigen then offer up their own division of the globe based on "world regions" rather than continents. Under such a scheme, Europe would become Western Eurasia, while the Western Hemisphere would become North America, Ibero-America, and African-America (divisions based on linguistic, cultural, and/or racial criteria). Whether or not you agree with the authors' division of the world, The Myth of Continents is a lively and thought-provoking exploration of a subject many of us take for granted. After reading this book, you'll never look at a map of the world in quite the same way.
Review
The very fact that their work stimulates such questions is a tribute to the authors. In The Myth of Continents, Lewis and Wigen have written an entertaining and informative account of the way our maps show us the world that we want to see. -- The New York Times Book Review, Michael Lind
From the Inside Flap
"Despite the recent surge of interest in geographical concepts and ideas, most social, cultural, and political studies are riddled with unexamined spatial assumptions. The Myth of Continents initiates a much-needed consideration of this state of affairs. Through a wide-ranging analysis of such metageographical constructs as East, West, Europe, and Asia, Lewis and Wigen provide provocative insights into the nature and significance of the ways we usually divide up the world. Moreover, they do so in an engaging and highly readable style. Readers of The Myth of Continents will never again see the world regions in quite the same way."—Alexander B. Murphy, author of The Regional Dynamics of Language Differentiation in Belgium
"An exciting, thoughtful, engaging, innovative book that demonstrates the need to reexamine commonly held assumptions about the world's division into continents, East/West, First/Second/Third World, etc. Readers will be drawn to its 'big-think' quality of shattering commonly held assumptions and to its up-to-the-minute contemporary feel."—Benjamin Orlove, coeditor of State, Capital, and Rural Society: Anthropological Perspectives on Political Economy in Mexico and the Andes
"An important and long overdue housecleaning of old geographical concepts, based upon an impressively wide reading of regional literatures."—Edmund Burke III, editor of Struggle and Survival in the Modern Middle East
Most helpful customer reviews
33 of 35 people found the following review helpful.
better than Edward Said or Samuel Huntington
By A Customer
I'm surprised to be the first to review this book. It was recommended to me a couple of years ago by a professor and I've only now gotten around to reading it: it's definitely one of the best books I've read recently.
As the title suggests, the book explores the myth of continents. The authors show the origin of the idea of the continent in ancient Greece and show its continued use throughout the centuries even as the addition of the Americas and Australia to the world map caused more and more incongruities with the original Greek and medieval world system.
The authors also look at the concepts of 'East' and 'West' and the similarly overused (but underdefined) 'Orient' and 'Occident', arguing against Edward Said for the continuation of a world divided into geographical regions, albeit ones that does not draw upon geographical determinism or cartographic ethnocentrism. Unlike Samuel Huntington they stress their world regions (i.e. African-America and Central Asia) as not always coherent territories with distinct borders. Agreeing with Herodotus and Toynbee about the need to examine the continental system, they thoroughly discuss the philosophical and political views of continents in recent centuries, looking at Rousseau, Herder, Hegel, Montesquieu, H.G. Wells, J. Burckhardt, Wallerstein and others.
This book is so good at deconstructing the built-up assumptions of the aforementioned terms that I hesistate to list any faults, although I should at least mention that I would have liked a few more maps and a separate section on how and why the authors chose each world region and its borders (i.e. why not a separate region for Madagascar).
In any case, this is a convincing and powerful book.
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful.
"East is East and West is West...
By Amazon Customer
...and never the twain shall meet." Kipling was wrong about that. This fascinating book shows how culture and world-view influenced not just Kipling and others of the past, but continues to do so with us today. Our maps, both mental and otherwise, are largely shaped by our own realities. Indeed the authors argue we are all unwitting believers in THE MYTH OF CONTINENTS. The metageography that this book critiques is defined as "the set of spatial structures through which people order their knowledge of the world." Such structures are arbitrary, but it's not just continents. It extends to world regions, culture areas, zones, and even civilizations. Also any depiction in atlases, on globes, in texts, and on political maps. It's all extremely subjective.
One of the strengths of this book is how it shows these artificial views emerging, changing, and adjusting to the dynamism and power of cultures. The concept of the continent of Europe is directly connected to the power of that region. Why else, the authors ask, should India be a sub-continent and China only a part of Asia? "In physical, cultural and historical diversity, China and India are comparable to the entire European landmass, not to a single European country."
The book traces the origins of the continental system from Herodotus through Ptolemy, the Romans, Medieval Europe to the Age of Discovery and beyond. The whole idea of what defined a continent (large landmass seperated by water) was always very fungible. The authors say that as late as 1599 "any reasonable large body of land or even island group might be deemed a continent". They give the example of a geographer referring to the West Indies as a "large and fruitful continent". The West Indies themselves are a perfect example of perception dictating form. We know that the "Indies" part came about because Columbus thought he had arrived in the East. The metageographies of West and East then are concepts that, like continents, are open to criticism. So too are the New and Old worlds, the First and Third Worlds (was there ever a Second World?) The same vagueness surrounds the North and the South, the Occident and Orient, Far East, Middle East, South Asia and the Pacific Rim.
In offering their own system for organizing human space the authors replace continents with "world regions". Arnold Toynbee and more recently Samuel Huntinton's system of using civilizations as the organizing principle gets a nod from the authors. In the classification they use, Europe is now "Western Eurasia", "African-America" includes not just the West Indies but the entire Caribbean and North-Eastern Brazil. North America remains and Ibero-America emerges.
Obviously geographers will thoroughly enjoy this book but it has a much broader appeal. Wherever we are in the world we use some of the terms above to describe our place. If nothing else this book will make us all a little more aware of how we define ourselves and others.
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful.
Continental divides
By John C. Landon
This stimulating challenge to conventional geography should be an essential ingredient to your next upgrade of your metageographical basics, world history as one for a change. The book is a nice debriefing of the several myths that distort that history. One of the main culprits is the East-West divide, whose illusory divide as to culture obsesses too many, butis one of the chief offenders, along with the notion of a 'western civilization' whose boundaries, content and latent ethnocentricism deserve a reminder that the East was always built into the West and vice versa. The Greek myth of Europa was always misleading, no? and isn't the realm of the Israelites the East, then?
One of the liabilities of Toynbean style analysis into 'civilizations' has been the failure to see the inherent unity of one 'Civilization' emerging in a series of partially diffentiated versions, rendering the many distinctions misleading, and quite tribalistic. A good example is the case of Japan which modernized sooner than much of Europe, it is a question of 'information', not of continents.
Fascinating take on 'metageography' and a good rolfing of some archaic concepts we take for granted.
The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography, by Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen PDF
The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography, by Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen EPub
The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography, by Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen Doc
The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography, by Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen iBooks
The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography, by Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen rtf
The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography, by Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen Mobipocket
The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography, by Martin W. Lewis, Kären Wigen Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar